Pellet Grill vs Gas Grill vs Flat Top Grill

•  Average Rank: 2.0 (CNET: 1, Serious Eats: 2, Smoked BBQ Source: 3).
• Price: ~$1,800-$2,000, a premium pick for its 924 sq. in. cooking area and WiFire app.

Shop on Amazon 

• Price: ~$800-$1,000 Shop Traeger Pro 575 (#).
• Why It’s the Best: The Traeger Pro 575 is a standout for ease of use, with WiFire app connectivity for remote temp control. Its temperature accuracy maintains set temps within 15°F, ideal for smoking ribs or chicken, per Wirecutter (2025). With 575 sq. in. of cooking space, it’s great for families. The powder-coated steel body ensures durability, lasting years with proper care, as social media users note: “Traeger Pro 575 is my go-to for effortless BBQ!” (@BBQFan123, 2025). While searing is limited, its smoky flavor and smart features make it a top pick.

Shop on Amazon 

Gas grills run on propane or natural gas, offering quick ignition and precise temperature control. They’re perfect for weeknight grilling and high-heat searing, with minimal cleanup.

Average Rating: 4.6/5 (Based on The Spruce Eats, Food & Wine, Consumer Reports)

• The Spruce Eats: 4.7/5, praised for quick heating and even cooking.
• Food & Wine: 4.5/5, noted for user-friendly controls.
• Consumer Reports: 4.6/5, lauded for searing and durability.

Pros:

• Quick Heating: Ignites in minutes, reaching 500°F+ for searing.
• Ease of Use: Push-button ignition and dial controls simplify operation.
• Excellent Searing: High BTUs deliver crusty steaks and grill marks.
• Easy Cleaning: Grease trays and removable grates streamline maintenance.

Cons:

• Less Flavor: Lacks the smoky depth of pellet or charcoal grills.
• Fuel Costs: Propane tanks add ongoing expenses.
• Flare-Ups: Grease can cause occasional flare-ups, requiring attention. 

• Average Rank: 1.5 (Food & Wine: 1, The Spruce Eats: 2, Consumer Reports: 1).
• Price: ~$900-$1,000, valued for its 787 sq. in. cooking area and multi-zone cooking.

Shop on Amazon

• Price: ~$600-$700 Shop Weber Spirit E-310 (#).
• Why It’s the Best: The Weber Spirit E-310 excels in temperature accuracy, with a built-in gauge accurate within 10°F, per Serious Eats (2025). Its ease of use comes from responsive controls and a 529 sq. in. cooking area, perfect for burgers or steaks. The cast-aluminum body ensures durability, resisting rust for over a decade, as a user on social media shared: “My Weber Spirit is 5 years strong, still grills like new!” (@GrillGuy22, 2025). It’s ideal for quick, high-heat grilling, though it lacks smoky flavor.

Shop on Amazon

Flat top grills, or griddles, use propane for a smooth cooking surface, ideal for breakfast, stir-fries, or smashed burgers. They’re less about grill marks and more about even, versatile cooking.

Average Rating: 4.4/5 (Based on Popular Mechanics, The Spruce Eats)

• Popular Mechanics: 4.5/5, praised for even heating and versatility.
• The Spruce Eats: 4.3/5, noted for easy cleaning but grease management issues.

Pros:

• Versatile Cooking: Perfect for pancakes, eggs, stir-fries, or burgers.
• Even Heating: Flat surface ensures consistent temps across the cooking area.
• Ease of Use: Simple propane ignition and dial controls.
• Large Cooking Area: Models like Blackstone offer 700+ sq. in. for big meals.

Cons:

• No Smoky Flavor: Lacks the wood-fired taste of pellet grills.
• Grease Management: Requires careful cleanup to avoid clogs.
• Less Portable: Heavier than gas grills, harder to move.

Average Rank: 1.5 (Popular Mechanics: 1, The Spruce Eats: 2).

• Price: ~$400-$500, loved for its 756 sq. in. cooking area and dual-zone cooking.

Shop on Amazon

Also Rated Best Flat Top Grill Under $1,000

• Why It’s the Best: The Blackstone 36-Inch Griddle is a powerhouse for ease of use, with four burners and dial controls for precise heat zones, per Popular Mechanics (2025). Its temperature accuracy ensures even cooking across 756 sq. in., ideal for breakfast or large gatherings. The steel frame offers durability, with  social media users noting, “Blackstone griddle holds up through rain and shine!” (@BBQMom45, 2025). Grease management needs attention, but its versatility makes it a top pick for griddle fans.